Devoir de Philosophie

THOSE MYSTIFYING AMERICANS

Publié le 07/02/2012

Extrait du document

People never really escape from their origins. So if you are about to visit the U.S.A., perhaps you should focus for a moment, not on the modern American, but on his ancestor, the seventeenth-century settler who, having survived the grim Atlantic crossing, found himself with his back to the sea facing a vast and hostile wildemess that had to be tamed and conquered if he was to survive. Many of the basic attitudes and characteristics formed in that struggle persist in Americans today. You may find sorne admirable, and others Jess so. The point is, they are there....

« whether they set out to conquer polio or land a man on the moon, Americans are convinced that initiative, inteUigent planning and hard work will bring about the desired conditions sooner or later.

ARTHUR GORDON, Those mystifying Americans.

1.

Commentaire dirigé 1) Do you think the writer is fair or one-sided when he speaks of the Americans? 2) What were the problems surrounding "that earl y American" settler? What were the qualities required of him to face these problems? 3) Do you think that the modern American bas kept and improved the frontiersman 's qualities? 4) In your opinion can initiative and hard work solve the problems of modern society? 2.

Version Traquire depuis "ln sorne parts of the world" jusqu'à la fin du texte .

.

1) Do you think that the writer is one-sided when he speaks of the Americans? The writer is definitely one-sided when he speaks of the Americans.

His considerations about the "ancestors" and the pioneers are only focused on the good points of these people.

According to him, their qualities of courage and opti- mism allowed them to eonquer an untamed territory, and to "civilize" the wilderness.

Though this opinion bas been the Si l'auteur a un parti­ pris, vous devez essayer de le démolir en citant tous les arguments contraires.. »

↓↓↓ APERÇU DU DOCUMENT ↓↓↓

Liens utiles