Devoir de Philosophie

Doris Lessing, The Fifth Child, ''Ben and his gang'' p. 145 ''Some weeks after'' to p. 149 ''popular mood or movement''

Publié le 25/06/2012

Extrait du document

lessing

I)    England in the eighties

A) There is one law for the rich, and one law for the poor, everybody knows that. p. 149 Margaret Thatcher (1979-1980) industrial privatisation policy: privatisation of British Gas, British Telecom, the Water Authorities, British Airways and the electricity industry created a new class of British shareholders (the new rich: people who afford to buy a few shares of the privatised industrial corporations). At the same time, however, impoverishing of another part of the British society: miners victims of the closing of pits in spite of massive strike, increasing number of young people out of work unemployment hit UKs destitute big cities causing riots, increased crime rate.[1] However this explanation must be qualified, as violence had been on the rise ever since the 60’s under far better economic conditions.[2] (See also the social and economic background in the extract “The happy family”)


[1]Criminologists offered substantial evidence in support of the positive correlation, especially between urban deprivation and decay, youth unemployment and levels of recorded crime” p. 76 from Thatcher and Thatcherism, by Eric J. Evans

[2] According to Thatcher herself, “riots, football hooliganism and crime generally had been on the increase since the 1960s” p. 22 id.

lessing

« Doris Lessing, The Fifth Child, “Ben and his gang” p.

145 “Some weeks after” to p.

149 “popular mood or movement” Page 2 of 8 p.

38 Also, many economic crises with several recessions (1973 and the oil shock, 1981 and 1990) with the fear of inflation.

iii) responsible because a) utter laziness: “one after another, three girls came to help; th ey had just left school and could not easily find work.

They were not much good.

[…] They came or didn’t come as the mood took them, and would sit around drinking tea with their girl -friends while Harriet toiled.” p.

41 “Another girl came in from the villa ge, found by Dr Brett.

She was, like the other three, pleasant, lazy, seeing nothing to be done unless her attention was directed to it” p.

47 “Who wants to do an honest job these days? said Dorothy.” [about the three girls] p.

43- 44 Dorothy’s reproach against young people not altogether fair: as John for example did try to find some “odd jobs”, thought it is true they were idle most of the time, and “hung about on pavements, sat around in cafés” (p.

110 -111) b) inherent violence: Ben’s physical strength and uncontrollable violence (see the extract “Family breakdown”, “The institution”, “Ben’s birth” for example) are symptomatic of the youths’ violence and barbary as a whole, independent of any economic explanation C) The gang ’s eating habits on p.

146 (in this extract) but also on pp.

149 and 154 → a cosmopolitan England with people coming from all around the world due partly to England’ s colonial past and partly maybe to an emerging or well -developed globalisation “Pizzas, and quiches; Chinese food, and Indian; pita bread with salad; tacos, tortillas, samosas, chili con carne; pies and pasties and sandwiches.

These were the conventional and hidebound English, were they?” p.

154 → We cannot but perceive a sense of nostalgia in the last sentence (from the part of Harriet?), a false question betraying a bitter sweet irony of what the English identity had become.

As a matter of fact, this internationalisation of the English society and what some may call the perversion of English culture did not come without resistance → rise of the racism and xenophobia → growing popularity of the National Front → violence between Asian communities and White English population for example (fights between these communities in Bradford in 1982) See the movie “ This is England” II) Television and family A) TV programmes: “They liked the afternoon soap operas, did not turn off the children’s programmes; but best of all they enjoyed the bloody fare of the evening.

Shootings and killings and tortures and fighting […] the bullets poured into a body, as blood spurted, as the tortured victims screamed.” p.

146 -147 i) Examples of TV programmes (BBC 1936, ITV 1954, Channel 4 1982) a) soap opera: EastEnders 1985 (social realism: rape, racial prejudice, unemployment, Down syndrome), Coronation Street 1960, Brooksi de 1982 (social realism too: drug abuse, homosexuality) b) series • Century Falls: Tess Hunter arrives with her mother in Century Falls, a village devoid of children where the natives are far from friendly, and downright hostile when they discover Mrs Hunter is pregnant.

But Tess isn't the only new arrival in Century Falls.

The rather strange Ben Naismith and his twin Carey have been summoned to the village, after being sent away many years ago → a kind of similarity with Harriet ’s unwelcome fifth pregnancy, and an eponymous Ben who was also rejected like the fifth child in our novel.

• The Clangers: A series about a family of knitted aliens eking out a threadbare existence on a bleak and cold world.

The Clangers are small, pink mouselike. »

↓↓↓ APERÇU DU DOCUMENT ↓↓↓

Liens utiles